Outback car smash victim awarded $9m

Outback car smash victim awarded $9m

27.09.2008
Outback car smash victim awarded $9m
Outback smash ... Paul Imbree has been awarded almost $9 million after a car accident left himparalysed from the neck down.

  • Man left paralysed by car accident
  • Sues unlicensed teen driver and Qantas
  • Awarded $9 million

A MAN left paralysed from the neck down after an unlicensed teenage driver rolled their 4WD on an outback road in the Northern Territory was yesterday awarded almost $9 million by the High Court.

The judgment in Paul Imbree`s case comes after the High Court overturned a long-standing precedent about learner drivers` level of responsibility.

Mr Imbree was relieved by the payout, saying it meant the difference between living at home in Caringbah or going into a nursing home.

"It`s enabled me to continue living a family life," he said.

 "It enables me to employ carers to come here and keep me going from day to day."

Mr Imbree fractured his spine when his son`s friend Jesse McNeilly, 16, swerved to avoid debris and crashed on a gravel road in the Northern Territory in April 2002.

Mr Imbree yelled at Mr McNeilly, telling him to brake, but the teen turned sharply and accelerated, rolling the vehicle.

Mr Imbree, 50, was left a tetraplegic, only able to move from the neck up.

He sued Mr McNeilly and his employer, Qantas - which owned the vehicle - for negligence in the Supreme Court.

His damages of $9.5 million were reduced by 30 per cent for contributory negligence, with the court finding he assumed a risk of injury by letting the teenager drive.

Mr Imbree`s payout was cut again to $3.7 million on appeal, with Mr McNeilly and Qantas arguing inexperience was the main factor and Mr Imbree held greater responsibility.

Mr Imbree then took his case to the High Court, challenging a 1986 finding that an unqualified, inexperienced driver had a lesser duty of care than other drivers.

The finding meant parents, rather than compulsory third-party insurers, were liable for the risk of injury when teaching youngsters to drive, his lawyers argued.

Mr Imbree succeeded, with the High Court ruling last month that a learner driver should be subject to the same standard of care as any other driver.

Law Society of NSW president Hugh Macken said the ruling gave "certainty and consistency to the law of negligence by applying the same standard to drivers, irrespective of their age and experience".


NEWS.com.au is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Share stories with friends in a click. Get your favourite NEWS.com.au content on your social networking profile.

Paul Imbree
Outback smash ... Paul Imbree has been awarded almost $9 million after a car accident left himparalysed from the neck down.

Today`s Top Picks


Font size: +-

Send this article:PrintEmail

Video

]

Advertisement

Tools
Share this article:

09/27/2008 Government gives markets $4bn protection
THE Federal Government will invest an initial $4 billion to boost competition in the mortgage market, which has been stifled by the global credit crunch
09/27/2008 Still no agreement on bailout
US politicians are still grappling to hammer out an $840bn Wall Street bailout and reassure jittery markets
09/27/2008 Rocketman flies into the record books
SWISS adventurer Yves Rossy has flown from England to France with a jetpack strapped to his back
09/27/2008 Heinz named in deadly milk scandal
CHINA`S toxic milk scandal has escalated with baby cereal made by one of the world`s most popular brands, Heinz, pulled off shelves

Today`s Top Picks


Font size: +-

Send this article:PrintEmail

Video

Advertisement

Tools

HURRICANE Ike is bearing down on the coast of Texas, driving a wall of water into seaside communities and threatening catastrophic damage all the way up to Houston.

In what may be the worst storm to hit Texas in nearly 50 years, Ike`s centre was within hours of overwhelming low-lying areas near Houston with a possible 20-foot (6-metre) storm surge.

High winds and rain lashed the coast, sending huge waves crashing against a 17-foot (5-metre) sea wall built to protect the port of Galveston after a hurricane in 1900 killed at least 8000 people in the deadliest weather disaster in US history.


Sign Stormpulse: Track Hurricane Ike
Sign Wikipedia: About Hurricane Ike
Gallery In pictures: Storms batter Haiti
Gallery In pictures: Here comes Gustav
Gallery In pictures: New Orleans evacuated

The National Weather Service warned that people in coastal areas could "face the possibility of death" and officials said Ike could flood as many as 100,000 homes and send a storm wave across 100 miles (180 km) of US coastline.

"Our nation is facing what is by any means a potentially catastrophic hurricane," said US Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, warning that the storm surge could present the gravest danger.

"This certainly falls in the category of pretty much a worst case scenario," he said.

Crude oil markets nervously watched to see if Ike would swamp low-lying coastal refineries in its path that collectively process 20 percent of U.S. fuel supplies.

Ike`s ferocity surprised many just 11 days after Hurricane Gustav forced 2 million people to flee the Louisiana coast, but largely spared New Orleans.

Some 600,000 people left low lying Texas counties under mandatory evacuation orders, but some who thought they would stick it out made a last-minute exit from Galveston.

"When I woke up, my bed was floating in the house," said David Daubuisson, a handyman who narrowly escaped from his home in Bayou Vista.

"I just took what I could and got out."

Ike was a Category 2 storm with 110 mph (175 kph) winds as it moved on a course to pass directly over Houston - the fourth-largest city in the United States.

The storm is expected to come ashore this afternoon, possibly as a dangerous Category 3 hurricane on the five-step intensity scale with winds of more than 111 mph (178 kph), the National Hurricane Centre said.

13 million could be without power

About 13 million people in 132 counties along the Gulf coast could face hurricane and tropical storm conditions, the US National Census Bureau said.

Millions of residents could be left without power, authorities said. A dawn-to-dusk curfew was laid down in evacuated areas around Houston.

The Coast Guard had to rescue 65 people from rising waters on the the Bolivar Peninsula, east of Galveston.

US crude oil futures rose 31 cents to settle at $US101.18 a barrel after dropping below $US100 for the first time since early April as concerns over US economic weakness outweighed storm disruption fears.

Ports were closed and the Coast Guard said a 584-foot (178-metre) freighter with 22 people aboard was stranded without power 90 miles (145 km) southeast of Galveston. Conditions were too treacherous to attempt a rescue.

Huge wave of water

The storm`s wide reach means that it will pack an unusually strong punch, taking the form of a huge wave of water it is pushing ahead of it.

"This is a Category 5 hurricane," said Jeff Masters, co-founder of meteorological Web site The Weather Underground.

"I don`t care what the Category 2 rating says," he said. Category 5 storms are the most dangerous.

The storm surge could push as far inland as NASA`s Johnson Space Center south of Houston, Mr Masters said.

Houston airports were closed and hotels were jammed with those seeking shelter.

Ike could be the third-most damaging storm in US history behind Hurricanes Katrina and Andrew in 1992, experts said.

Risk Management Solutions pegged the value of insured property in the Houston area at nearly $US1 trillion, including the city`s port - the nation`s second busiest.

Katrina devastated New Orleans and other parts of the Gulf Coast in August 2005, killing 1500 people and causing at least $US81 billion in damage.

The costliest storm in US history, Katrina also damaged President George W. Bush`s standing and his administration was heavily criticised for its slow response to the disaster.

- Additional reporting by Anna Driver, Eileen O`Grady, Erwin Seba and Bruce Nichols

NEWS.com.au is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Share stories with friends in a click. Get your favourite NEWS.com.au content on your social networking profile.

Today`s Top Picks


Font size: +-

Send this article:PrintEmail

Video

Advertisement

Tools
Hurricane Ike could be `catastrophe`   09/13/2008
01. 2009
Mo Tu Wd Th Fr Sa Su
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031


Google


Categories: News Headlines Business News Entertaiment News Hi-tech & Science Sport
Global: Americas Europe Africa Australia Asia Middle East